Intuition vs. Calculation Exercise in Climate Adaptation Decisions

Close Icon
These competencies are explicitly fostered and described in Competence View.
These competencies are fostered in this course but are not explicitly described in Competence View. Please contact the responsible person for further information. Competencies in grey are fostered in this course but are generally not the focus of Competence View, which focusses on cross-disciplinary competencies.

In the course Climate Change Uncertainty and Risk, students learn to navigate climate adaptation as a decision-making problem under uncertainty rather than a purely technical exercise. Moving beyond standard modelling, the course challenges students to confront how analytical results, economic reasoning and personal values interact when making real-world choices about risk and resilience. Through deliberately simple but provocative exercises, students experience the tension between intuition and calculation. This format is designed to expose hidden assumptions and foster critical reflection on the limits of “rational” economic decision-making in climate contexts. Building their own programming-based analyses, students then shift from calculation to action by developing stakeholder-focused policy briefs. They define concrete climate risks, identify a relevant decision-maker and formulate implementable recommendations grounded in their results. This requires them to translate technical insights into clear, persuasive arguments and to take responsibility for a position in a real-world context.

Learning outcomes

After completing this course, students will be able to:

  • Apply programming and economic calculations to analyze climate risks and adaptation options.
  • Analyze how assumptions, values, and uncertainty affect decisions, and compare intuitive vs. model-based outcomes.
  • Evaluate adaptation strategies in terms of effectiveness, feasibility, and fairness.
  • Create stakeholder-focused policy briefs that translate analysis into clear, evidence-based recommendations.
I try to bring deeper questions to the floor through very simple practical questions. As soon as you introduce concepts like discounting climate risks, people realize that what felt obvious before suddenly changes.“
„
“
Prof. Dr. David N. Bresch

Teaching Activity: Intuition vs. Calculation Exercise

The exercise begins with the instructor posing a question for students to answer through a poll, which is presented in a way to trigger student’s baseline perspectives, such as: “How much money would you invest today to avoid large climate damages in the future?”. Students provide their individual answers and the instructor then displays the class-wide range of answers to highlight differences in students’ baseline perspectives. Students discuss motivations and differences in polling answers with their neighbors.

To further ground the discussion, the instructor then introduces a climate-related dilemma related to the initial questions, such as: “you build a dam that hits exactly 10 years from now… The damage is 20 million, the dam costs 10 million, and every second-year maintenance is 1 million. So, 15 million in investment to avoid 20 million in damage.” Based on their initial intuition, the students vote on whether they would fund and build the dam.

The instructor then introduces a variable that disrupts the initial calculation (e.g. a discount rate of 2%), outlining how the initial “rational” decision can flip depending on economic assumptions. The exercise concludes in a plenary where students discuss their shift from economic to systemic thinking, assessing how their personal values interact with financial considerations.

Lesson Sequence

Time

Personnel

Preparation
In-Class
Follow-Up

Instruction

Sequence of activities before, during, and after the teaching activity

Before

  • Prepare an anonymous polling question to catch intuitive responses to a climate-related economic dilemma.
  • Prepare a simple case study illustrating the underlying economic concept (e.g., discounting).

During

  • Collect and discuss students’ intuitive responses.
  • Introduce additional information (eg, a discount rate) that challenges the initial decision.
  • Facilitate reflection among students on their initial underlying assumptions and how their perspectives may have changed.

After

  • Review response data from polls to determine whether the students grasped frictions between their intuition and economic models.

Assessment

The teaching activity functions as a formative learning exercise. Students engage with climate-related economic concepts through a practical dilemma. Through this format, key competencies are fostered:

  • Analytical competencies and Critical Thinking: through students evaluating cost-benefit models and economic variables, actively changing their opinions or assumptions in light of new information.
  • Decision-making: through students having to make concrete choices on whether to fund certain investments, basing initial choices on intuition and refining them as financial and economic variables are introduced.
  • Self-awareness & self-reflection: by prompting students to reflect on their own baseline perspectives and observe how their perspectives and thinking shift over the course of the exercise.
  • Communication: by having students present their own perspectives and explain reasoning behind polling answers to peers in a plenary discussion format.

Transfer tips

When transferring this teaching activity to other course contexts and settings, there are a few noteworthy points to keep in mind:

  • Ensure that polling is anonymous , as it will allow students to answer more honestly.
  • Use simple but provocative dilemmas ; start with an intuitive question or decision that most students feel confident answering, then introduce additional information that challenges their initial assumptions.
  • Keep the complexity mathematical to a minimum , as the goal is not to have students practice calculations but rather to illustrate their conceptual pivot from their initial intuitions on a dilemma.
  • Focus on reasoning rather than correct answers , using the exercise to explore how different assumptions, values, and decision frameworks lead to different conclusions.

Course Description

Name:
Climate Change Uncertainty and Risk: From Probabilistic Forecasts to Economics of Climate Adaptation
Description:
The course introduces the concepts of predictability, probability, uncertainty and probabilistic risk modelling and their application to climate modeling and the economics of climate adaptation.
Objective:
Students will acquire knowledge in uncertainty and risk quantification (probabilistic modelling) and an understanding of the economics of climate adaptation. They will become able to construct their own uncertainty and risk assessment models (in Python), hence basic understanding of scientific programming forms a prerequisite of the course.
VVZ:
701-1252-00L
Department:
D-USYS
Level:
Master
Format:
Project-Based Education (PBE), Case-based learning
Size:
Maximum 80 students
Cohort:
Agricultural Sciences Master, Data Science Master, Integrated Building Systems Master, Physics Master, Science, Technology, and Policy Master, Environmental Sciences Master
Type:
Elective
Assessment:
Graded semester performance based on tutorials during the semester

loading